Who should pick which
Pick Appstle if…
- you want build-a-box, bundles, SMS notifications or Shopify POS subscriptions, which ZS does not offer
- you want an app with thousands of reviews and a long track record (Appstle has been listed since April 2021)
- you sell a few high-priced subscriptions, so your revenue stays inside a low Appstle tier
- you want 24/7 chat support, which Appstle lists
Pick ZS Subscriptions if…
- you sell many lower-priced subscriptions (coffee, tea, supplements) and want the bill tied to subscriber count, not revenue
- you want API and webhooks without asking for an enterprise plan
- you want the app itself in your language: ZS is listed in 21 languages
- you want someone to do the move and setup for you at no cost
Features side by side
| Feature | ZS Subscriptions | Appstle |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | ✓ 50 subscriptions, any revenue | ✓ up to $500 a month in subscription revenue |
| What the price is based on | Number of subscriptions | Monthly subscription revenue |
| Transaction fee | 0% | 0% stated on paid plans |
| Subscribe and save, prepaid | ✓ | ✓ |
| Memberships | ✓ tags the customer for members-only access | ✓ |
| Recurring invoices | ✓ | not listed |
| Customer portal: skip, pause, swap, reschedule | ✓ customer must be logged in | ✓ passwordless login from Starter |
| Failed-payment retries | ✓ you set retries and the delay | ✓ |
| Cancellation flow (offer before cancelling) | ✓ paid plans | ✓ Business |
| Build-a-box | — | ✓ Business |
| Loyalty discounts | ✓ after a number of renewals, Business | ✓ Starter |
| SMS notifications | — | ✓ Starter |
| API and webhooks | ✓ listed | listing says ‘ping us for enterprise, APIs & webhook’ |
| Shopify Flow | ✓ | ✓ |
| Shopify POS | not listed | ✓ |
| Import subscribers from another app | ✓ one CSV; reads Seal, Recharge, Appstle and Loop exports | ✓ ‘hands-on migration’ on the Free plan |
| App languages | 21 | English |
| Support | Email, contact form and WhatsApp; free setup | ‘24/7 human support’ (listing) |
| Rating on the App Store | 5.0 from 1 review | 5.0 from 9,248 reviews |
✓ = listed · — = not offered · ‘not listed’ = not on the listing. Appstle details from its Shopify App Store listing on 12 Nov 2026. ZS plan names are from the ZS listing.
Pricing
Appstle Subscriptions
| Plan | Price | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | Up to $500 a month in subscriptions |
| Starter | $10/month or $96/year | Up to $5,000 a month in subscription revenue |
| Business | $30/month or $288/year | Up to $15,000 a month |
| Business Premium | $100/month or $960/year | Up to $100,000 a month |
As listed on the Shopify App Store on 12 Nov 2026. Paid plans list a 14-day free trial and 0% transaction fee; the listing says add-ons from higher plans are available à la carte, and to contact Appstle for enterprise, APIs and webhooks.
ZS Subscriptions
| ZS Subscriptions plan | Price | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | 50 subscriptions; regular and prepaid plans; 0% transaction fee |
| Starter | $2.29/month or $22.68/year | 100 subscriptions |
| Pro | $9.95/month or $95.40/year | 500 subscriptions |
| Business | $35.95/month or $359.40/year | 2,000 subscriptions |
| In the app | Growth $3.95/month; bigger plans | 250 subscriptions (Growth); larger plans up to 150,000 |
ZS Subscriptions charges no transaction fee and no usage charges; the price depends only on how many subscriptions you have. Prices as listed on the Shopify App Store on 12 Nov 2026.
What this means in practice. 300 subscribers paying $25 a month is $7,500 of monthly subscription revenue: that is Appstle’s Business plan ($30/month) and ZS’s Pro plan ($9.95/month, up to 500 subscriptions). The other way round, 1,500 subscribers at $8 is $12,000 a month: Appstle Business is still $30, while ZS needs Business at $35.95. So ZS is usually cheaper when you have many lower-priced subscriptions, and Appstle can be cheaper when you have fewer, higher-priced ones. Check with your own numbers.
Why merchants switch from Appstle
Appstle’s listing showed 64 reviews of 1 to 3 stars on 12 Nov 2026 (41 one-star, 12 two-star, 11 three-star), against more than 9,000 five-star reviews. We read all of them; the counts below are approximate because one review often raises several points:
- Support that did not solve the problem: the most common topic, raised in about half of them. Several say replies were quick but the issue stayed open.
- Something broke after an update: about 20 mention bugs or changes rolled out live that broke the widget, the portal or billing.
- Migrations that went wrong: about 10 describe a move from Recharge, Bold or another app that took weeks or mixed up data.
- Setup spread across many screens: about 12 found the settings hard to work through or the customer portal confusing for shoppers.
- Cost, or features behind higher plans and paid add-ons: about 10, including 3 about API or webhook access.
- Payment method limits: 4 mention Shop Pay, Sage Pay or Authorize.net problems.
- Translations: up to 4 mention languages, mostly that translating the storefront needed another app.
What ZS does about them: the CSV import reads an Appstle export as it is and skips cancelled subscriptions; API and webhooks are listed with the app rather than on an enterprise plan; widget and portal text can be translated in Settings › Translations; and our team does the move for you. What ZS does not change: subscriptions run on Shopify subscription contracts in both apps, so payment-gateway limits set by Shopify apply to ZS too, and ZS is a young app with one review, so it has no long support record yet.
Switching from Appstle? We set it up for you free
Zilancer, the team behind ZS Subscriptions, does the setup for you at no cost: we import your subscribers, check prices, intervals and next billing dates against Appstle, add the widget and the customer portal to your theme, and tell you when it is safe to turn Appstle off. Export your subscriptions from Appstle as a CSV and send it to us, or upload it yourself under Subscriptions › Import.
- Install from the Shopify App Store listing (the Free plan needs no card).
- Then message us on the contact page, by email at contact@zilancer.com, or on WhatsApp at +880 1408 270201.
When Appstle is the better choice
- You need build-a-box, bundles, SMS or POS subscriptions. Appstle lists all four; ZS has none of them.
- You want a proven track record. Appstle shows 5.0 from more than 9,000 reviews. ZS has one review.
- Your subscriptions are few but expensive. Revenue-based tiers can then cost less than per-subscriber tiers.
- You want round-the-clock chat support. Appstle lists 24/7 human support; ZS support is email, the contact form and WhatsApp.
Questions
Sources: Appstle Subscriptions on the Shopify App Store and its 1–3 star reviews, and the ZS Subscriptions listing, read on 12 Nov 2026. Features and prices change, so check each listing before you decide.
More comparisons: Recharge alternative · Switching from Seal · Appstle alternative · Loop alternative · ZS vs Shopify Subscriptions · Move subscriptions to Shopify