Who should pick which
Pick Shopify Subscriptions if…
- you want a free app made by Shopify, with nothing else to pay for at any size
- you sell simple subscribe-and-save with a weekly, monthly or yearly interval
- you sell subscriptions in person on Shopify POS
- your customers only need to skip, pause or cancel
Pick ZS Subscriptions if…
- you need prepaid plans, memberships, recurring invoices or a fixed delivery date for everyone
- customers should swap products or reschedule themselves, or skip from the reminder email
- you want failed-payment retries, a cancellation flow and CSV export
- you want a person to set it up with you, free
Features side by side
| Feature | ZS Subscriptions | Shopify Subscriptions |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free up to 50 subscriptions; paid from $2.29/month | Free |
| Transaction fee | 0% | none listed |
| Built on Shopify subscription contracts | ✓ renewals create Shopify orders | ✓ made by Shopify |
| Subscribe and save with a discount | ✓ | ✓ weekly, monthly or yearly |
| Prepaid plans | ✓ | not listed |
| Memberships and recurring invoices | ✓ | not listed |
| Fixed schedules (same date for everyone) | ✓ Pro | not listed |
| Customer can skip, pause or cancel | ✓ | ✓ |
| Customer can swap products or reschedule | ✓ automated swaps from Starter | not listed |
| Skip or pause from the reminder email | ✓ one click | not listed |
| Failed-payment retries you configure | ✓ number of retries and the delay | not listed |
| Cancellation flow (offer before cancelling) | ✓ paid plans | not listed |
| Reports | ✓ statistics, retention, upcoming revenue, inventory forecast | ✓ subscription performance reporting |
| Export subscribers to CSV | ✓ | not listed |
| Import from another app | ✓ one CSV from Seal, Recharge, Appstle or Loop | ✓ ‘transfer existing subscription contracts’ |
| Shopify POS | not listed | ✓ |
| Shopify Flow | ✓ created, renewed, payment failed, cancelled | not listed |
| Edit widget and portal text / translations | ✓ Settings › Translations | email templates are customisable |
| App languages | 21 | 19 |
| Support | Zilancer team by email, contact form, WhatsApp; free setup | Shopify support |
| Rating on the App Store | 5.0 from 1 review | 3.8 from 902 reviews |
✓ = listed · ‘not listed’ = not on its App Store listing (it may still be covered in Shopify’s help docs). Shopify Subscriptions details from its Shopify App Store listing on 12 Nov 2026.
Pricing
Shopify Subscriptions is free: its listing shows a single Free price on 12 Nov 2026.
| ZS Subscriptions plan | Price | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | 50 subscriptions; regular and prepaid plans; 0% transaction fee |
| Starter | $2.29/month or $22.68/year | 100 subscriptions |
| Pro | $9.95/month or $95.40/year | 500 subscriptions |
| Business | $35.95/month or $359.40/year | 2,000 subscriptions |
| In the app | Growth $3.95/month; bigger plans | 250 subscriptions (Growth); larger plans up to 150,000 |
ZS Subscriptions charges no transaction fee and no usage charges; the price depends only on how many subscriptions you have. Prices as listed on the Shopify App Store on 12 Nov 2026.
If the free app does what you need, keep it. ZS’s Free plan is also $0 for 50 subscriptions, and its paid plans only make sense if you will use the extra tools.
Why merchants move on from the free app
Shopify Subscriptions shows 3.8 from 902 reviews, with 358 reviews of 1 to 3 stars on 12 Nov 2026 (167 one-star, 74 two-star, 117 three-star). We read the latest 30 of each, 90 in all. Counts are approximate, as one review often raises several points. Most are not about bugs but about missing options:
- Not flexible enough: the biggest theme, in about a third of the 90: no way to change the next order date, add one-off items, set a fixed date or use day-based intervals such as every 45 days.
- Customers struggle to manage their own subscription: about 10 say shoppers could not pause, skip, cancel or change details easily, or the manage link did not work.
- Weak reporting and search: about 10 want upcoming-order dates, churn data, search and export.
- Bugs: about 10 describe errors, such as a variant that could not be added to the cart, or failed charges after a card update.
- Hard to reach support: about 5 say there was no one to ask.
- Text and language: about 4 could not change the wording or localise it.
What ZS adds for these: fixed schedules (Pro), customer-side reschedule and product swaps, one-click skip or pause from the reminder email, upcoming-revenue and inventory-forecast reports, CSV export of your subscribers, editable widget and portal text, and a team you can contact. What ZS does not add: Shopify POS subscriptions are not listed for ZS, and ZS has one review, so it does not have Shopify’s track record. Both apps use Shopify subscription contracts, so payment limits that come from Shopify apply to both.
Switching from Shopify Subscriptions? We set it up for you free
Zilancer, the team behind ZS Subscriptions, does the setup for you at no cost: we import your subscribers, check prices, intervals and next billing dates against Shopify Subscriptions, add the widget and the customer portal to your theme, and tell you when it is safe to turn Shopify Subscriptions off. Both apps use Shopify subscription contracts, so your subscribers and their saved cards stay in Shopify; we bring them into ZS with one CSV.
- Install from the Shopify App Store listing (the Free plan needs no card).
- Then message us on the contact page, by email at contact@zilancer.com, or on WhatsApp at +880 1408 270201.
When Shopify Subscriptions is the better choice
- Simple needs. One discount, a few intervals, and customers who only skip, pause or cancel.
- Selling on Shopify POS. The free app lists POS support.
- Zero cost at any size. It is free however many subscriptions you have; ZS is free only up to 50.
- A first-party app. It is made and maintained by Shopify.
Questions
Sources: Shopify Subscriptions on the Shopify App Store and its 1–3 star reviews (latest 30 of each), and the ZS Subscriptions listing, read on 12 Nov 2026. Features and prices change, so check each listing before you decide.
More comparisons: Recharge alternative · Switching from Seal · Appstle alternative · Loop alternative · ZS vs Shopify Subscriptions · Move subscriptions to Shopify